Ankle Sprain Differential Diagnosis: A Comprehensive Guide

Acute ankle sprains are extremely common musculoskeletal injuries encountered across various healthcare settings, from primary care to emergency rooms. While often perceived as minor, ankle sprains can lead to significant short-term discomfort, recurrent injuries, and lasting functional instability if not properly evaluated and managed. Accurate initial assessment is crucial to mitigate these risks and ensure appropriate treatment strategies are implemented. This article delves into the differential diagnosis of ankle sprains, providing a comprehensive overview for healthcare professionals to enhance diagnostic accuracy and patient care.

Understanding Ankle Sprains: Etiology, Epidemiology, and Pathophysiology

Ankle sprains predominantly involve damage to the ligaments of the ankle joint, most frequently the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) and the calcaneofibular ligament (CFL). These injuries occur due to a variety of mechanisms, ranging from low-energy events like missteps during walking to high-energy sports-related trauma. The severity of an ankle sprain, classified from Grade I (mild stretch) to Grade III (complete tear), dictates the extent of ligamentous damage and potential instability. Understanding the mechanism of injury—whether inversion, eversion, or rotational—is a critical first step in considering the differential diagnosis. High-grade sprains may also involve the syndesmotic ligaments, often referred to as “high ankle sprains,” which require different management approaches.

Epidemiologically, ankle sprains are remarkably prevalent. Millions of cases are treated annually in emergency departments worldwide, highlighting the widespread nature of these injuries. They are the most common injury in sports, affecting athletes across various disciplines. Recurrence rates are also substantial, with a significant percentage of individuals experiencing persistent symptoms, repeated sprains, and chronic ankle instability following an initial injury. This underscores the importance of not only acute management but also comprehensive rehabilitation and preventative strategies.

The ankle joint’s complex anatomy, comprising the tibia, fibula, and talus, is stabilized by three main ligament groups: the lateral ligament complex, the medial deltoid ligament, and the syndesmotic ligaments. Lateral ankle sprains, by far the most common, typically result from ankle inversion, stressing the lateral ligament complex in a predictable sequence: ATFL, CFL, and less often, the posterior talofibular ligament (PTFL). The ATFL, being the weakest, is most frequently injured. Medial deltoid ligament injuries, caused by eversion forces, are less common due to the ligament’s strength. Syndesmotic injuries, or high ankle sprains, result from forceful external rotation and/or dorsiflexion, and while less frequent than lateral sprains, are important to recognize due to their potential for prolonged recovery and different treatment pathways.

Clinical Evaluation: History and Physical Examination for Differential Diagnosis

A meticulous clinical evaluation is paramount in differentiating an ankle sprain from other conditions presenting with similar symptoms. This process begins with a detailed history and progresses to a thorough physical examination, utilizing specific tests to assess ligamentous integrity and rule out other pathologies.

History Taking: Uncovering Clues to the Injury

The patient history should meticulously document the mechanism of injury. Inquire about the direction of force – was it an inversion, eversion, rotational stress, or direct impact? Understanding the mechanism helps narrow down the likely injured structures. A history of previous ankle injuries is also crucial, as prior sprains increase the risk of recurrence and may indicate pre-existing ligamentous laxity. Furthermore, assess the patient’s immediate weight-bearing ability after the injury. Inability to bear weight immediately or at the time of evaluation is a significant indicator that may necessitate radiographic evaluation to rule out fractures, as guided by the Ottawa ankle rules.

Physical Examination: Inspection, Palpation, and Functional Tests

The physical examination should systematically evaluate the ankle and foot.

Inspection: Begin by visually inspecting the ankle and foot for swelling, ecchymosis (bruising), and deformity. Plantar ecchymosis, in particular, may suggest a Lisfranc injury.

Palpation: Palpate key anatomical structures to pinpoint areas of tenderness. Systematically assess:

Lateral Ligaments: Palpate the ATFL anterior to the lateral malleolus, the CFL inferior to the lateral malleolus, and the PTFL posterior to the lateral malleolus.
Medial Ankle: Palpate along the course of the deltoid ligament.
Fibula: Crucially, palpate the entire fibula, including the proximal aspect. Proximal fibular tenderness should raise suspicion for a Maisonneuve fracture, a subtle but serious injury often associated with ankle sprains.
Foot: Palpate the base of the fifth metatarsal, the navicular bone, and the midfoot to assess for foot fractures and Lisfranc injuries, respectively.

Functional Tests: Several specific tests assess ligamentous stability and syndesmotic involvement:

Anterior Drawer Test: Evaluates ATFL integrity. Stabilize the distal tibia and fibula with one hand, and grasp the calcaneus with the other. With the ankle in 20 degrees of plantarflexion, pull the calcaneus anteriorly. Increased anterior translation compared to the uninjured side suggests ATFL laxity.

Alt text: Anterior drawer test demonstrating grade 3 ankle sprain with anterior talus translation, indicating ATFL ligament laxity.

Talar Tilt Test: Assesses CFL integrity. Stabilize the distal leg and invert the calcaneus. Excessive talar tilt compared to the uninjured side indicates CFL laxity.

Alt text: Talar tilt stress radiograph showing varus talar positioning, indicative of grade 3 ankle sprain and lateral ligament complex injury.

Squeeze Test: Evaluates syndesmotic injury. Compress the tibia and fibula at mid-calf level. Pain at the syndesmosis indicates a positive test.
External Rotation Stress Test: Assesses syndesmotic injury. With the ankle in slight dorsiflexion, externally rotate the foot. Pain at the syndesmosis is a positive finding.

It is important to note that the anterior drawer and talar tilt tests may be falsely negative acutely due to pain and muscle spasm. Re-examination after initial pain and swelling subside may be necessary.

Ottawa Ankle Rules: Guiding Radiographic Evaluation

The Ottawa ankle rules are evidence-based clinical decision rules designed to minimize unnecessary radiographs in ankle and foot injuries. They are highly sensitive for detecting fractures and are valuable in the initial evaluation process.

Ankle Radiographs are indicated if there is pain in the malleolar zone AND any of the following:

Tenderness at the posterior edge or tip of the lateral malleolus (distal 6 cm)
Tenderness at the posterior edge or tip of the medial malleolus (distal 6 cm)
Inability to bear weight immediately and for four steps at evaluation

Foot Radiographs are indicated if there is midfoot pain AND any of the following:

Tenderness at the base of the fifth metatarsal
Tenderness at the navicular bone
Inability to bear weight immediately and for four steps at evaluation

These rules are not applicable in all situations, such as in patients with distracting injuries, altered mental status, or diminished lower extremity sensation. However, when appropriately applied, they significantly reduce the need for radiographs while maintaining a low miss rate for fractures.

Differential Diagnosis of Ankle Sprains: Distinguishing Conditions

The differential diagnosis of ankle sprains encompasses a range of conditions that can mimic sprain symptoms. Accurate differentiation is crucial for guiding appropriate management and preventing complications.

Ankle Sprain (Lateral, Medial, Syndesmotic): While “ankle sprain” is the primary diagnosis, it’s essential to differentiate between lateral, medial, and syndesmotic sprains as management and prognosis can vary. Lateral sprains are the most common, involving the lateral ligament complex. Medial sprains are less frequent, involving the deltoid ligament. Syndesmotic or “high ankle sprains” involve the ligaments connecting the tibia and fibula above the ankle joint.
High Ankle Sprain and Syndesmotic Injury: These injuries, while technically a type of ankle sprain, are distinct in mechanism, location, and often require a longer recovery. They involve the syndesmotic ligaments and typically result from external rotation or dorsiflexion forces. Clinical examination findings like a positive squeeze test and external rotation test are key indicators. Imaging, including radiographs and sometimes MRI, may be necessary to assess the extent of syndesmotic injury.
Ankle Fractures: Fractures around the ankle, including malleolar fractures (lateral, medial, bimalleolar, trimalleolar) and distal tibia/fibula fractures, must be ruled out, especially in higher energy injuries or when Ottawa ankle rules are positive. Radiographs are essential for diagnosis. Stress fractures, although less acute, should also be considered in athletes with gradual onset of pain.
Subtalar Dislocation: This is a less common but significant injury involving dislocation of the subtalar joint (between the talus and calcaneus). It usually results from high-energy trauma and presents with significant deformity and inability to bear weight. Radiographs are diagnostic.
Lisfranc Injuries: These injuries involve the ligaments and bones of the midfoot. They can be subtle but are crucial to diagnose as missed Lisfranc injuries can lead to chronic pain and dysfunction. Mechanism often involves axial loading of a plantarflexed foot. Physical exam findings such as midfoot pain, swelling, and plantar ecchymosis, along with radiographic findings, are diagnostic.
Maisonneuve Fracture: This is a fracture of the proximal fibula associated with an ankle injury, typically due to eversion forces. The key to diagnosis is recognizing that proximal fibular pain in the setting of an “ankle sprain” should prompt radiographs of the entire tibia and fibula. These injuries involve syndesmotic disruption and often deltoid ligament injury, requiring surgical fixation.
Peroneal Tendon Injuries: Peroneal tendonitis, tenosynovitis, subluxation, or tears can mimic lateral ankle sprain symptoms. Pain is often located posterior to the lateral malleolus, and resisted eversion may exacerbate symptoms. Careful palpation along the peroneal tendons and specific tendon testing can help differentiate these conditions. MRI or ultrasound may be needed for definitive diagnosis.
Osteochondral Lesions of the Talus (OLTs): These cartilage and bone injuries within the ankle joint can occur acutely with sprains or develop chronically. They may present with persistent pain, swelling, clicking, or catching in the ankle, sometimes mimicking chronic ankle instability after a sprain. MRI is the imaging modality of choice for diagnosing OLTs.
Achilles Tendon Rupture: While presenting posteriorly, Achilles tendon ruptures can sometimes be confused with severe ankle injuries. The mechanism is typically a sudden push-off or eccentric loading. Physical exam findings, including a palpable gap in the tendon and a positive Thompson test (absent plantarflexion when squeezing the calf), are diagnostic.

Imaging Modalities for Differential Diagnosis

While clinical examination is the cornerstone of differential diagnosis, imaging plays a crucial role in confirming or excluding certain conditions.

Radiographs (X-rays): Essential for ruling out fractures based on Ottawa ankle rules or clinical suspicion. Standard ankle views (AP, lateral, mortise) and foot views are typically obtained. Weight-bearing views may be necessary to assess syndesmotic widening or subtle fractures. Stress radiographs, such as anterior drawer and talar tilt views, can be used to quantify ligamentous laxity, though are often performed later in the healing process if instability is suspected.
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI): The gold standard for soft tissue evaluation. MRI is highly sensitive for detecting ligament tears, syndesmotic injuries, tendon pathologies (peroneal, Achilles), osteochondral lesions, and bone bruises not visible on radiographs. MRI is typically reserved for cases with persistent symptoms, suspected high-grade sprains, syndesmotic injuries, or to evaluate for intra-articular pathology.
Ultrasound: Can be useful for evaluating superficial soft tissues, including ligaments and tendons. Ultrasound is less sensitive than MRI for intra-articular pathology but can be a cost-effective and readily available option, particularly for assessing peroneal tendon issues or fluid collections.

Treatment and Management Considerations Based on Differential Diagnosis

Treatment strategies are dictated by the specific diagnosis. While the PRICE protocol (Protection, Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation) is a cornerstone for initial management of ankle sprains and many related conditions, further management diverges based on the underlying pathology.

Ankle Sprains (Grades I-III): PRICE therapy, pain management (NSAIDs or acetaminophen), and early functional rehabilitation are key. Weight-bearing as tolerated with support (bracing, elastic bandage) is generally preferred over immobilization for most lateral ankle sprains. Physical therapy focuses on restoring range of motion, proprioception, strength (especially peroneal muscles), and neuromuscular control to prevent recurrence.
Syndesmotic Injuries: Management ranges from non-operative to surgical depending on severity and instability. Non-operative treatment may include prolonged non-weight-bearing and immobilization for less severe sprains. Surgical intervention, such as screw or suture-button fixation, is often required for syndesmotic diastasis or instability to stabilize the tibia and fibula and allow for syndesmotic ligament healing.
Ankle Fractures: Management depends on fracture type, stability, and displacement. Stable, non-displaced fractures may be treated non-operatively with immobilization. Unstable or displaced fractures typically require open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) to restore anatomical alignment and joint stability.
Subtalar Dislocations and Lisfranc Injuries: These often require orthopedic consultation and surgical management to reduce the dislocation or stabilize the midfoot to restore proper anatomy and function.
Maisonneuve Fractures: Require surgical fixation. The fibular fracture itself may be fixed, but more importantly, the syndesmotic disruption needs to be addressed, often with syndesmotic screws or suture buttons, and deltoid ligament repair may also be necessary.
Peroneal Tendon Injuries and OLTs: Management varies based on the specific pathology and severity, ranging from conservative measures like physical therapy and orthotics to surgical repair or debridement.
Achilles Tendon Rupture: Treatment options include non-operative casting or bracing and surgical repair. Surgical repair is often favored in younger, more active individuals to improve strength and reduce re-rupture risk.

Prognosis and Complications

The prognosis and potential complications vary significantly based on the accurate initial diagnosis and subsequent management. Most uncomplicated ankle sprains have a good prognosis with appropriate conservative treatment and rehabilitation, with full recovery within weeks to months. However, up to 40% of patients may experience chronic symptoms, recurrent sprains, or chronic ankle instability.

Potential complications across the differential diagnoses include:

Chronic Pain and Disability: Inadequate management or missed diagnoses can lead to persistent pain, functional limitations, and reduced quality of life.
Recurrent Ankle Instability: Especially after lateral ankle sprains, if rehabilitation is incomplete or ligamentous laxity persists.
Osteochondral Lesions of the Talus: Can develop as a sequela of ankle sprains, leading to chronic pain and arthritis.
Post-traumatic Arthritis: May develop in the ankle or subtalar joint following fractures, dislocations, or severe ligamentous injuries.
Peroneal Tendon Dysfunction: Can result from untreated peroneal tendon injuries, leading to lateral ankle pain and instability.
Neurovascular Injury: Rare but possible in high-energy trauma, dislocations, or fractures.
Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS): A rare but debilitating complication that can occur after any ankle injury.

Enhancing Diagnostic Accuracy and Healthcare Team Approach

Optimizing diagnostic accuracy in ankle injuries requires a collaborative, interprofessional team approach. This includes:

Thorough History and Physical Examination Skills: Healthcare professionals, including physicians, physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and athletic trainers, need to be proficient in performing comprehensive ankle examinations and applying clinical decision rules like the Ottawa ankle rules.
Appropriate Imaging Utilization: Judicious use of radiographs and advanced imaging based on clinical findings and guidelines is essential.
Clear Communication and Referral Pathways: Effective communication between primary care providers, emergency physicians, orthopedic specialists, and physical therapists is crucial for timely and appropriate referrals when necessary, particularly for complex injuries or when differential diagnoses are less clear.
Patient Education: Educating patients about the importance of proper rehabilitation, bracing, and preventative measures is vital to minimize recurrence and optimize long-term outcomes.

Alt text: Radiographic image showing medial gutter widening, indicating acute ankle sprain with deltoid and syndesmotic ligament insufficiency.

Conclusion

Accurate differential diagnosis is paramount in the management of ankle injuries. While ankle sprains are common, a range of other conditions can present with similar symptoms. A systematic approach, combining a detailed history, meticulous physical examination, appropriate use of the Ottawa ankle rules, and judicious imaging when indicated, is essential for differentiating ankle sprains from fractures, syndesmotic injuries, tendon pathologies, and other mimicking conditions. By enhancing diagnostic accuracy and fostering a collaborative healthcare team approach, we can optimize patient care, minimize complications, and improve long-term outcomes for individuals presenting with ankle injuries.

References

Koutras C, Antoniou SA, Jäger M, Heep H. Acute Injuries Sustained By Racing Drivers: A Cross-Sectional Study. Acta Orthop Belg. 2017 Dec;83(4):512-520. PubMed: 30423656
Swords M, Brilhault J, Sands A. Acute and Chronic Syndesmotic Injury: The Authors’ Approach to Treatment. Foot Ankle Clin. 2018 Dec;23(4):625-637. PubMed: 30414657
Slater K. Acute Lateral Ankle Instability. Foot Ankle Clin. 2018 Dec;23(4):523-537. PubMed: 30414650
Carto C, Lezak B, Varacallo M. StatPearls [Internet]. StatPearls Publishing; Treasure Island (FL): Aug 8, 2023. Anatomy, Bony Pelvis and Lower Limb: Distal Tibiofibular Joint (Tibiofibular Syndesmosis) PMC free article: PMC547655 PubMed: 31613435
Bridgman SA, Clement D, Downing A, Walley G, Phair I, Maffulli N. Population based epidemiology of ankle sprains attending accident and emergency units in the West Midlands of England, and a survey of UK practice for severe ankle sprains. Emerg Med J. 2003 Nov;20(6):508-10. PMC free article: PMC1726220 PubMed: 14623833
Doherty C, Bleakley C, Delahunt E, Holden S. Treatment and prevention of acute and recurrent ankle sprain: an overview of systematic reviews with meta-analysis. Br J Sports Med. 2017 Jan;51(2):113-125. PubMed: 28053200
Wang DY, Jiao C, Ao YF, Yu JK, Guo QW, Xie X, Chen LX, Zhao F, Pi YB, Li N, Hu YL, Jiang D. Risk Factors for Osteochondral Lesions and Osteophytes in Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability: A Case Series of 1169 Patients. Orthop J Sports Med. 2020 May;8(5):2325967120922821. PMC free article: PMC7252382 PubMed: 32518802
Mauntel TC, Wikstrom EA, Roos KG, Djoko A, Dompier TP, Kerr ZY. The Epidemiology of High Ankle Sprains in National Collegiate Athletic Association Sports. Am J Sports Med. 2017 Jul;45(9):2156-2163. PubMed: 28423285
Ponkilainen VT, Laine HJ, Mäenpää HM, Mattila VM, Haapasalo HH. Incidence and Characteristics of Midfoot Injuries. Foot Ankle Int. 2019 Jan;40(1):105-112. PubMed: 30269512
Khan IA, Varacallo M. StatPearls [Internet]. StatPearls Publishing; Treasure Island (FL): Aug 8, 2023. Anatomy, Bony Pelvis and Lower Limb, Foot Talus. PubMed: 31082130
Ehrlichman LK, Gonzalez TA, Macaulay AA, Ghorbanhoseini M, Kwon JY. Gravity Reduction View: A Radiographic Technique for the Evaluation and Management of Weber B Fibula Fractures. Arch Bone Jt Surg. 2017 Mar;5(2):89-95. PMC free article: PMC5410750 PubMed: 28497098
Kerkhoffs GM, Rowe BH, Assendelft WJ, Kelly K, Struijs PA, van Dijk CN. Immobilisation and functional treatment for acute lateral ankle ligament injuries in adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2002;(3):CD003762. PubMed: 12137710
Vuurberg G, Hoorntje A, Wink LM, van der Doelen BFW, van den Bekerom MP, Dekker R, van Dijk CN, Krips R, Loogman MCM, Ridderikhof ML, Smithuis FF, Stufkens SAS, Verhagen EALM, de Bie RA, Kerkhoffs GMMJ. Diagnosis, treatment and prevention of ankle sprains: update of an evidence-based clinical guideline. Br J Sports Med. 2018 Aug;52(15):956. PubMed: 29514819
Strudwick K, McPhee M, Bell A, Martin-Khan M, Russell T. Review article: Best practice management of common ankle and foot injuries in the emergency department (part 2 of the musculoskeletal injuries rapid review series). Emerg Med Australas. 2018 Apr;30(2):152-180. PubMed: 29235235
Wight L, Owen D, Goldbloom D, Knupp M. Pure Ankle Dislocation: A systematic review of the literature and estimation of incidence. Injury. 2017 Oct;48(10):2027-2034. PubMed: 28826653
Sprouse RA, McLaughlin AM, Harris GD. Braces and Splints for Common Musculoskeletal Conditions. Am Fam Physician. 2018 Nov 15;98(10):570-576. PubMed: 30365284
Barelds I, van den Broek AG, Huisstede BMA. Ankle Bracing is Effective for Primary and Secondary Prevention of Acute Ankle Injuries in Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analyses. Sports Med. 2018 Dec;48(12):2775-2784. PubMed: 30298478