Congenital diaphragmatic hernia (CDH) is a birth defect that occurs when there is an opening in the diaphragm, the muscle that separates the chest and abdominal cavities. This defect allows abdominal organs to move into the chest cavity, hindering lung development. Occurring in approximately 1 to 4 out of every 10,000 births, CDH is a significant concern due to the potential for serious health issues in newborns, primarily lung hypoplasia and pulmonary hypertension. While survival rates for CDH have improved, ranging from 69% to 93%, with isolated CDH cases around 85%, early and accurate prenatal diagnosis remains crucial for optimal management and care.
What is Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia?
Congenital diaphragmatic hernia is characterized by a hole in the diaphragm, which develops during fetal development. This diaphragmatic defect allows organs from the abdomen, such as the stomach, intestines, liver, and spleen, to herniate or move into the chest cavity. This displacement of organs into the chest puts pressure on the developing lungs, leading to lung hypoplasia (underdevelopment of the lungs) and pulmonary hypertension (high blood pressure in the arteries of the lungs). These conditions are the primary causes of breathing difficulties and other complications in newborns with CDH.
Prenatal Diagnosis of CDH
Prenatal diagnosis of congenital diaphragmatic hernia is typically achieved through routine ultrasound scans during pregnancy. These scans can often detect CDH as early as the second trimester. Identifying CDH before birth is incredibly important as it allows for:
- Preparation for specialized care: Prenatal diagnosis enables healthcare providers to plan for delivery and immediate postnatal care in specialized centers equipped to manage CDH.
- Assessment of prognosis: Prenatal assessments, including ultrasound markers like liver herniation, stomach herniation, and Lung-to-Head Ratio (LHR), help in predicting the severity of CDH and potential outcomes.
- Parental counseling and support: Knowing about the diagnosis prenatally allows parents to understand the condition, seek information, and prepare emotionally and practically for the challenges ahead.
CDH Laterality: Right vs. Left Sided
CDH is more commonly found on the left side of the fetus (Left-sided CDH or LCDH) than on the right side (Right-sided CDH or RCDH). Approximately 85% of CDH cases are left-sided, while only about 15% are right-sided. The side of the hernia, known as laterality, has been a subject of research to understand if it impacts the prognosis and outcomes for infants with CDH.
Previous studies have presented varied findings on the impact of CDH laterality. Some research suggested that right-sided CDH might lead to worse outcomes, while others indicated improved or similar outcomes compared to left-sided CDH. These discrepancies in findings might be due to smaller sample sizes in studies focusing on the less common right-sided CDH, variations in treatment approaches across different institutions, and differences in whether cases were diagnosed prenatally or postnatally.
Study on CDH Laterality and Prenatal Diagnosis
To address the uncertainties surrounding CDH laterality and its impact on outcomes, a retrospective cohort study was conducted at a single institution, focusing on prenatally diagnosed CDH cases. This study aimed to compare outcomes between right-sided CDH (RCDH) and left-sided CDH (LCDH), specifically looking at infant survival and antenatal ultrasound predictors of poor prognosis.
Methods
The study reviewed cases of CDH diagnosed prenatally and evaluated at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) Fetal Treatment Center between 2008 and 2016. The researchers compared 32 cases of right-sided CDH with 157 cases of left-sided CDH. The primary outcome measured was survival to hospital discharge. Secondary outcomes included various prenatal ultrasound findings known to predict poor prognosis, such as liver herniation, stomach herniation, and Lung-to-Head Ratio (LHR), as well as other factors like concurrent anomalies, hydrops fetalis, preterm birth, and the need for ECMO (Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation).
Key Findings
The study revealed several significant findings regarding the differences between right-sided and left-sided CDH in prenatally diagnosed cases:
- Liver Herniation: Right-sided CDH was significantly associated with a higher rate of liver herniation (90.6%) compared to left-sided CDH (72%).
- Hydrops Fetalis: Hydrops fetalis, a condition characterized by excessive fluid accumulation in fetal tissues and cavities, was also significantly more frequent in right-sided CDH (15.6%) compared to left-sided CDH (1.3%).
- Lung-to-Head Ratio (LHR): Fetuses with right-sided CDH had a statistically significant lower median LHR compared to those with left-sided CDH, suggesting potentially smaller lung volume.
- Stomach Herniation: Conversely, left-sided CDH showed a higher rate of stomach herniation (69.4%) compared to right-sided CDH (12.5%).
- Survival to Discharge: Despite the differences in ultrasound predictors, the study found that survival to hospital discharge was similar for both right-sided CDH (64%) and left-sided CDH (66.4%).
Discussion of Findings
The study’s results indicate that while prenatal ultrasound markers associated with poor prognosis, such as liver herniation, hydrops fetalis and lower LHR, are more prevalent in right-sided CDH, these differences do not translate into a difference in survival to hospital discharge when compared to left-sided CDH. This suggests that other factors, such as the degree of lung hypoplasia, pulmonary hypertension management, and overall neonatal care, may play more critical roles in determining survival outcomes than the laterality of the CDH itself.
The higher incidence of liver herniation in right-sided CDH is notable, as liver herniation is a known predictor of poorer prognosis in CDH. Similarly, the increased occurrence of hydrops fetalis in right-sided CDH raises questions about the underlying mechanisms and its impact on neonatal outcomes. However, the equivalent survival rates suggest that perhaps the severity of these ultrasound markers, rather than their mere presence, or the effectiveness of postnatal care protocols, are more crucial determinants of survival.
Limitations of the study include its retrospective nature and single-center design, which may limit the generalizability of the findings. Additionally, the study primarily focused on short-term outcomes (survival to discharge) and did not extensively examine longer-term morbidities or neurodevelopmental outcomes. Future research should explore these longer-term aspects and investigate the interplay between CDH laterality, prenatal ultrasound markers, and various neonatal management strategies to further refine our understanding and improve outcomes for infants with congenital diaphragmatic hernia.
Conclusion
Prenatal diagnosis of congenital diaphragmatic hernia is essential for managing this complex condition. This study highlights that while right-sided CDH is associated with a higher prevalence of adverse prenatal ultrasound predictors like liver herniation and hydrops fetalis, it does not appear to result in decreased survival to hospital discharge compared to left-sided CDH in prenatally diagnosed cases. These findings are valuable for prenatal counseling, risk assessment, and guiding clinical management of CDH. Continued research is needed to further elucidate the factors that most significantly impact outcomes in CDH and to optimize care strategies for these infants.
References
The references are kept the same as in the original article.
[1] (#R1)
[2] (#R2)
[3] (#R3)
[4] (#R4)
[5] (#R5)
[6] (#R6)
[7] (#R7)–[13] (#R13)
[14] (#R14),[15] (#R15)
[16] (#R16),[17] (#R17)
[2] (#R2),[18] (#R18),[19] (#R19)
[8] (#R8),[17] (#R17),[20] (#R20),[21] (#R21)
[22] (#R22)
[17] (#R17)
[25] (#R25),[26] (#R26)
[24] (#R24)
[25] (#R25),[26] (#R26)
[15] (#R15),[27] (#R27),[28] (#R28)
[29] (#R29)
[30] (#R30)
[5] (#R5)
[31] (#R31)–[33] (#R33)
[34] (#R34)–[36] (#R36)
[6] (#R6),[37] (#R37)
[38] (#R38)–[40] (#R40)
[22] (#R22)
[15] (#R15),[27] (#R27),[28] (#R28),[41] (#R41)
[42] (#R42)
[43] (#R43)
[42] (#R42),[44] (#R44)
[45] (#R45)
[46] (#R46)
[22] (#R22)
[25] (#R25),[47] (#R47)
