Introduction
The accurate completion of a death certificate is a critical yet often challenging responsibility for healthcare practitioners. In the United States, physicians are primarily tasked with this duty when a death occurs. However, in cases involving suspected foul play or under specific legal circumstances, the responsibility shifts to a medical examiner or coroner. It’s important to note that physicians should not hesitate to certify a death, regardless of whether the manner of death is natural, suicide, homicide, accident, or undetermined, as the ultimate determination in these complex scenarios rests with the medical examiner. In specific situations, such as the death of a hospice patient when a physician is unavailable, a nurse practitioner might be authorized to complete the death certificate.
Properly filled death certificates are crucial. Incomplete or incorrectly filled documents are often rejected by vital statistics registrars. The death certificate serves as a public record, accessible to family members, researchers, legal professionals, and insurance companies, especially in cases of litigation.
The core purpose of a death certificate is to document the Death Diagnosis, specifically the immediate cause of death. This refers to the event, clinical condition, or disease process that directly led to the cessation of life. It is vital to differentiate between the cause of death and the mechanism of death. Terms like cardiac arrest, respiratory arrest, or “old age” are discouraged as they describe the mechanism, not the underlying cause. The focus should be on the etiology—the specific condition that initiated the fatal sequence of events.
The primary function of death certification extends beyond individual records. Governmental agencies rely on these certificates to compile vital statistics, providing essential official documentation of deaths and their causes. This data is not intended to be a comprehensive medical history but rather a focused record of the death diagnosis.
Globally, the World Health Organization (WHO) plays a pivotal role in mortality data collection and classification. This international standardization allows for comparisons across different countries, and the United States, as a signatory, adheres to WHO guidelines. Within the U.S., the National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS), a division of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), is responsible for collecting national mortality data. To maintain WHO standards, the NCHS periodically reviews the U.S. standard death certificate, ensuring each state complies with NCHS regulations to receive federal funding. Annually, approximately 2.6 million deaths are reported to the NCHS in the United States.
State-specific regulations dictate the timeframe for filing death certificates. For instance, in Wisconsin, the medical portion must be completed within six days of death. Falsifying information on a death certificate is a serious offense, classified as a felony.
Despite the importance of accuracy, studies reveal that errors occur in a significant percentage of death certificates, ranging from 33% to 41%. Cardiovascular diseases are often overrepresented as the primary cause of death in these errors. Common factors contributing to these inaccuracies include the inexperience of the certifying physician, particularly those in training, and insufficient training among attending physicians regarding death certification procedures. Educational interventions, such as seminars and workshops, have been shown to significantly improve the accuracy of death certification documentation.
A common misconception among healthcare professionals is that signing a death certificate may impose legal liabilities. However, it’s crucial to understand that a death certificate represents a medical opinion on the cause of death based on the best available information at the time. Lawsuits against death certifiers are exceedingly rare, and liability is seldom assigned to the certifier. Furthermore, death certificates are amendable, allowing for corrections or updates as new information emerges.
Function of the Death Certificate
In the United States, while the function and specific content fields of death certificates are largely consistent across states, they generally adhere to the U.S. standard death certificate format. The information captured can be broadly categorized into three main areas:
Demographics and Statistics
This section gathers essential identifying information about the deceased, including:
- Full Name
- Age at death
- Social Security Number
- Race or Ethnicity
- Gender
Method of Body Disposition
This part details the arrangements made for the deceased’s remains:
- Name of Funeral Home
- Crematorium (if applicable)
- Burial details
- Cemetery site
Death Information: Core of the Death Diagnosis
This section is paramount as it contains the critical details pertaining to the death diagnosis and circumstances:
- Date of Death
- Time of Death
- Manner of Death
Pronouncement of Death vs. Date and Time of Death
It’s important to distinguish between the pronouncement of death and the actual date and time of death. The pronouncement of death is the official declaration of legal death, made by a physician, medical examiner, or coroner. This might not always coincide with the actual time of death, especially in forensic cases or when a deceased individual is discovered after a period of time.
The date and time of death refer to when the individual is believed to have physiologically died. This may be an actual observed time or an estimated time, determined by medical professionals.
Cause of Death: Unraveling the Death Diagnosis
The cause of death section is the most clinically significant part of the death certificate, requiring a detailed death diagnosis. It necessitates outlining the sequence of events that ultimately led to death. This is further broken down into:
Immediate Cause of Death
This is the final condition or event directly preceding death, listed as the first diagnosis in Part I of the death certificate. For example, in the provided example, pulmonary edema is listed as the immediate cause.
Underlying Cause of Death
Conversely, the underlying cause of death is the condition that initiated the chain of events leading to death, situated furthest back in time. This is recorded last in Part I, at the bottom of the sequence. In the example provided, systemic lupus erythematosus is the underlying cause.
Conditions occurring between the immediate and underlying causes are termed intermediate causes.
Manner of Death: Classifying the Death Diagnosis
The manner of death categorizes the death based on the circumstances surrounding it. The classifications are:
- Natural: Death due solely to disease or the aging process.
- Accident: Unintentional death resulting from injury or poisoning.
- Homicide: Death resulting from the intentional actions of another person.
- Suicide: Death resulting from intentional self-inflicted injury.
- Undetermined: When the manner of death cannot be clearly classified after investigation.
Medical Certifier of Death and Electronic Death Registry
The Medical Certifier of Death is the healthcare professional responsible for completing the medical sections of the death certificate, including the date, time, cause, and manner of death.
The Electronic Death Registry System (EDRS) is widely used in the U.S. for the non-medical components of death certification, typically handled by the funeral director. This system enhances accuracy, timeliness, surveillance of mortality data, and overall efficiency. The funeral director inputs demographic and disposition information, then selects a medical certifier who receives a “Fax Attestation for Medical Certification” (though this may be electronic in modern systems). After the medical certifier completes their section, the funeral director can verify the information before it is officially registered. State statutes may introduce variations in this process.
Medical Certification of Death: Ensuring Accuracy in Death Diagnosis
Accuracy is paramount in medical death certification to ensure a correct death diagnosis. Dates should be recorded with day, month, and year, and time should be in 24-hour format (military time).
Part I and Part II of Cause-of-Death Section
Part I of the cause-of-death section is structured to capture the sequence of events leading to death in a structured manner, from the immediate to the underlying cause (lines Ia to Id). The most recent event (immediate cause) is on line a, progressing to more remote conditions. The underlying cause is listed last. The approximate interval between the onset of each condition and death should be noted in hours, days, weeks, or months.
Part II is used to list any other significant conditions that contributed to death but were not part of the direct causal sequence in Part I.
Examples of Completing the Cause-of-Death Section for Accurate Death Diagnosis
Example 1:
- Part I
- a. Pulmonary edema (2 days) due to or as a consequence of
- b. Anasarca (2 months) due to or as a consequence of
- c. Chronic renal failure (5 years) due to or as a consequence of
- d. Systemic lupus erythematosus (15 years)
- Part II
- Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (20 years)
- Manner of Death: Natural
- Autopsy: Yes/No
In this scenario, pulmonary edema is the immediate cause, with anasarca and chronic renal failure as intermediate causes linked to the underlying systemic lupus erythematosus. Specificity is crucial; for example, specifying “pulmonary” edema is more informative than just “edema.” Abbreviations and acronyms should be avoided for clarity in the death diagnosis.
Example 2:
- Part I
- a. Fat embolism (2 hours) due to or as a consequence of
- b. Chronic tissue hypoxia (12 years) due to or as a consequence of
- c. Sickle cell anemia (12 years)
- Part II
- Moderate persistent asthma (7 years)
- Manner of Death: Natural
- Autopsy: Yes/No
Here, fat embolism is the immediate cause, triggered by chronic tissue hypoxia secondary to sickle cell anemia (the underlying cause). Asthma is a contributing condition listed in Part II. Remember, the death certificate aims to identify the cause, not merely the mechanism of death (like cardiopulmonary arrest).
Issues of Concern in Death Diagnosis and Certification
Special Cases: Injuries and Non-Natural Deaths
Deaths resulting from injuries, whether in or out of a hospital, present unique considerations in death diagnosis. There is no statute of limitations for injury-related deaths. For instance, if a patient dies from sepsis following complications from a stab wound, even if sepsis is the immediate cause, the manner of death remains homicide due to the initial injury.
Falls leading to hip fractures in the elderly are common and can set off a cascade of events leading to death, such as sepsis or thromboembolism. In such cases, if pulmonary embolism develops due to prolonged immobilization post-hip fracture from a fall, the manner of death is classified as an accident. Even if an injury is listed in Part II, a non-natural cause will dictate the manner of death. Death certificates can be amended if necessary, based on new information. Injury or poisoning generally results in a non-natural manner of death classification.
Example: Injury-Related Death
- Part I
- a. Sepsis and septic shock
- b. Empyema and necrotizing pneumonia
- c. Knife wounds to the chest
- Part II
- Type 2 diabetes
- Manner of Death: Homicide
- Autopsy: Yes/No
Place and Mechanism of Injury
The death certificate should specify the place of injury, which could be a public location like a shopping mall, restaurant, or even the place of death pronouncement. Location details should include street address, zip code, and county. It should also indicate if the injury occurred at work, which is important for employer/employee related issues. The description of how the injury happened should be precise, e.g., “skiing accident, lost control and struck a tree,” or “motor vehicle collision, rear-ended and ejected.”
In cases of non-natural deaths, the medical examiner or coroner typically assumes responsibility for death certification.
Substance Abuse and Death Diagnosis
Both acute and chronic substance abuse can lead to death, requiring careful death diagnosis. Chronic alcohol abuse can cause conditions like pancreatitis, alcohol withdrawal seizures, or hepatic cirrhosis. Chronic IV drug abuse can lead to bacterial endocarditis, and long-term tobacco use can result in oral carcinoma or COPD. Deaths from chronic conditions related to substance abuse are generally classified as natural.
However, deaths directly resulting from acute drug toxicity, such as overdoses of cocaine, PCP, or opiates, are classified as either suicide or accident, depending on evidence of intent for self-harm. Deaths occurring as a consequence of therapeutic interventions, such as sepsis due to chemotherapy-induced bone marrow suppression, are classified as natural.
Physician-Assisted Suicide and Terminal Events
Physician-assisted suicide or euthanasia is classified as “other” or “unclassified” in some jurisdictions.
Terms describing terminal events such as electromechanical dissociation, ventricular fibrillation, asystole, or respiratory failure are non-specific and should be avoided when determining the death diagnosis on a death certificate, as they are mechanisms rather than causes of death.
Amending a Death Certificate: Refining the Death Diagnosis
Death certification relies on the best medical opinion at the time of completion. Recognizing that new information can emerge, most states have provisions to amend death certificates. If an autopsy is pending, it is advisable to wait for the results before finalizing the certificate. Some institutions have protocols for pathologists to consult with the original medical certifier to ensure consistency between autopsy findings and the certified cause of death. Medical examiners or coroners can also amend death certificates based on subsequent information.
Clinical Significance of Accurate Death Diagnosis
The clinical significance of accurate death diagnosis and death certification is profound. Birth and death records are fundamental vital statistics used by governments to plan for essential societal needs such as food, housing, healthcare, and education. Analyzing causes of death from death certificates is the cornerstone of vital statistics, guiding public health policy and resource allocation.
Other Issues: Brain Death and its Certification as a Death Diagnosis
Brain Death: A Neurological Death Diagnosis
Brain death is defined as the irreversible cessation of all brain functions, including the brainstem. This concept evolved with medical advancements like mechanical ventilation, which can sustain cardiopulmonary function despite complete brain function loss. Brain death is a clinical death diagnosis, determined through rigorous neurological examination. Confirmatory tests are available but not mandatory if clinical criteria are conclusively met.
Determination of Brain Death: Protocol for Death Diagnosis
The determination of brain death involves several steps:
- Establish Etiology: Identify a clear cause of irreversible brain damage, such as anoxic brain injury, severe head trauma, or fulminant hepatic encephalopathy.
- Exclude Reversible Conditions: Rule out conditions that can mimic brain death, including:
- Severe electrolyte imbalances
- Drug or toxin ingestion (CNS depressants, neuromuscular blockers, benzodiazepines)
- Hypothermia (core temperature < 32°C)
- Metabolic encephalopathies (hepatic, renal failure, hyperosmolar coma)
- Severe hypophosphatemia
- Neurological Examination: A detailed exam must demonstrate:
- Absence of spontaneous movements, including abnormal posturing
- No response to noxious stimuli
- Fixed, non-reactive pupils
- Absent brainstem reflexes (corneal, oculocephalic, oculovestibular, gag, cough)
- Apnea Test: This test assesses for respiratory drive:
- Prerequisites: Core temperature > 36.5°C (97°F), euvolemia, normal blood pressure, PaCO2 ≥ 45 mm Hg, and preoxygenation to PaO2 > 200 mm Hg.
- Procedure: Disconnect ventilator, administer 100% oxygen via T-tube or cannula, observe for spontaneous breathing, and draw arterial blood gases at 4-5 minute intervals for 8-10 minutes.
- Interpretation: Positive apnea test (supporting brain death death diagnosis) if no spontaneous breaths and PaCO2 > 60 mm Hg or ≥ 20 mm Hg rise from baseline. Negative if spontaneous breaths occur. Test must be terminated and patient re-ventilated if hypotension (SBP < 90 mm Hg), desaturation, or arrhythmias develop. Indeterminate if PaCO2 criteria not met. Confirmatory tests may be considered in indeterminate cases.
Confirmatory Tests for Brain Death Diagnosis
Confirmatory tests are ancillary and may be used to support the clinical death diagnosis of brain death:
- Angiography (conventional, MRI, CT): Absence of intracranial blood flow at the circle of Willis or carotid bifurcation.
- Electroencephalography (EEG): Absence of electrical brain activity.
- Nuclear Brain Scan (Cerebral Scintigraphy): Lack of radiotracer uptake by brain tissue.
- Transcranial Doppler Ultrasonography: Systolic peaks only, with absent diastolic flow, indicating high intracranial pressure and vascular resistance.
Brain Death in Children: Pediatric Death Diagnosis
Brain death determination in children is also clinical, with protocols similar to adults, but with specific considerations for age. Data for infants under 37 weeks gestation is insufficient, and these guidelines do not apply to them. Hypothermia, hypotension, and electrolyte imbalances must be corrected before brain death evaluation. Medications that could interfere with neurological exams or apnea testing should be discontinued. Two physician examinations are required, separated by an observation period:
- 24 hours for newborns to 30 days old.
- 12 hours for infants and children older than 30 days to 18 years.
The apnea test protocol is the same as for adults. Defer neurological assessment for at least 24 hours post-cardiopulmonary resuscitation or significant brain injury if inconsistencies exist.
Certification of Brain Death: Legal and Ethical Aspects of Death Diagnosis
A physician with institutional privileges can certify brain death. In New York State, organ donation cases require certification by both the attending physician and another physician to confirm adherence to accepted medical standards for brain death death diagnosis.
Documentation of brain death determination must include:
- Cause of irreversible coma
- Absence of motor responses to noxious stimuli
- Absence of brainstem reflexes in two exams at least 6 hours apart
- Apnea test results (absence of respiration with PaCO2 > 60 mm Hg)
- Justification for any ancillary confirmatory tests.
A death certificate can be issued after brain death is certified. Ventilator support can be discontinued post-brain death declaration. Sensitivity and respect for the family are paramount during this process, and institutional policies should address family concerns and provide support.
US Standard Death Certification Form
A visual representation of the US Standard Death Certificate form, highlighting key sections for demographic information, manner and cause of death, and certification details. This form is crucial for accurate death diagnosis and recording vital statistics.
References
1.Breaux S, Perez CA. Pitfalls in the use of death certificates for assessing cause of death: a study of tonsil carcinoma patients. Am J Clin Oncol. 1984 Aug;7(4):375-80. [PubMed: 6377867]
2.Klatt EC, Noguchi TT. Death certification. Purposes, procedures, and pitfalls. West J Med. 1989 Sep;151(3):345-7. [PMC free article: PMC1026895] [PubMed: 2588577]
3.Pritt BS, Hardin NJ, Richmond JA, Shapiro SL. Death certification errors at an academic institution. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2005 Nov;129(11):1476-9. [PubMed: 16253030]
4.Smith Sehdev AE, Hutchins GM. Problems with proper completion and accuracy of the cause-of-death statement. Arch Intern Med. 2001 Jan 22;161(2):277-84. [PubMed: 11176744]
5.Myers KA, Farquhar DR. Improving the accuracy of death certification. CMAJ. 1998 May 19;158(10):1317-23. [PMC free article: PMC1229326] [PubMed: 9614825]
6.Lakkireddy DR, Gowda MS, Murray CW, Basarakodu KR, Vacek JL. Death certificate completion: how well are physicians trained and are cardiovascular causes overstated? Am J Med. 2004 Oct 01;117(7):492-8. [PubMed: 15464706]
7.Lakkireddy DR, Basarakodu KR, Vacek JL, Kondur AK, Ramachandruni SK, Esterbrooks DJ, Markert RJ, Gowda MS. Improving death certificate completion: a trial of two training interventions. J Gen Intern Med. 2007 Apr;22(4):544-8. [PMC free article: PMC1839864] [PubMed: 17372807]
8.Cirera L, Salmerón D, Martínez C, Bañón RM, Navarro C. [More than a decade improving medical and judicial certification in mortality statistics of death causes]. Rev Esp Salud Publica. 2018 Jun 06;92 [PMC free article: PMC11587202] [PubMed: 29855461]
9.Brooks EG, Reed KD. Principles and Pitfalls: a Guide to Death Certification. Clin Med Res. 2015 Jun;13(2):74-82; quiz 83-4. [PMC free article: PMC4504663] [PubMed: 26185270]
10.Mieno MN, Tanaka N, Arai T, Kawahara T, Kuchiba A, Ishikawa S, Sawabe M. Accuracy of Death Certificates and Assessment of Factors for Misclassification of Underlying Cause of Death. J Epidemiol. 2016;26(4):191-8. [PMC free article: PMC4808686] [PubMed: 26639750]
11.Srivastava V, Nakra M, K AS, Dhull P, Ramprasad R, Lamba NS. Brain stem death certification protocol. Med J Armed Forces India. 2018 Jul;74(3):213-216. [PMC free article: PMC6081203] [PubMed: 30093762]
12.Al-Wali W, Deshmukh A, Hamed M, Shaukat A. Death certification reforms are an opportunity for wider quality improvement. BMJ. 2018 Aug 01;362:k3240. [PubMed: 30068657]
13.Wijdicks EF. Determining brain death in adults. Neurology. 1995 May;45(5):1003-11. [PubMed: 7746373]
14.Practice parameters for determining brain death in adults (summary statement). The Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology. 1995 May;45(5):1012-4. [PubMed: 7746374]
15.Wijdicks EF, Varelas PN, Gronseth GS, Greer DM., American Academy of Neurology. Evidence-based guideline update: determining brain death in adults: report of the Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology. 2010 Jun 08;74(23):1911-8. [PubMed: 20530327]
16.Belsh JM, Blatt R, Schiffman PL. Apnea testing in brain death. Arch Intern Med. 1986 Dec;146(12):2385-8. [PubMed: 3778074]
17.Goudreau JL, Wijdicks EF, Emery SF. Complications during apnea testing in the determination of brain death: predisposing factors. Neurology. 2000 Oct 10;55(7):1045-8. [PubMed: 11061269]
18.Nakagawa TA, Ashwal S, Mathur M, Mysore M., Committee For Determination Of Brain Death In Infants Children. Guidelines for the determination of brain death in infants and children: an update of the 1987 task force recommendations-executive summary. Ann Neurol. 2012 Apr;71(4):573-85. [PubMed: 22522447]
19.Kotabagi RB, Chaturvedi RK, Banerjee A. Medical Certification of Cause of Death. Med J Armed Forces India. 2004 Jul;60(3):261-72. [PMC free article: PMC4923180] [PubMed: 27407646]
