Abdominal pain is a frequent presentation in urgent care and emergency room settings. Diverticulitis, the inflammation or infection of small pouches in the colon, is a significant consideration in patients presenting with such pain. The key question for many is: when is diverticulitis diagnosis best handled in an emergency room versus an urgent care facility? This article provides a clinical update to help patients and healthcare providers understand the nuances of diverticulitis diagnosis, guiding you to make informed decisions about seeking care in the appropriate setting. We will explore the critical factors in differentiating between uncomplicated and complicated diverticulitis and outline the optimal pathways for diagnosis and initial management.
Understanding Diverticulitis and Diverticulosis
To understand diverticulitis, it’s important to first define diverticulosis. In 1849, French pathologist Jean Cruveilhier described diverticulosis as “bands of longitudinal muscle fibers in the sigmoid, a series of small, dark, pear-shaped tumors, which are formed by hernia of the mucous membrane through the gaps in the muscle coat.” Simply put, diverticula are small pouches that bulge outward from the colon wall. These outpouchings consist of the mucosa and submucosa pushing through the muscular layer of the colon, typically at points of weakness where blood vessels penetrate the bowel wall, as illustrated in Figure 1.
Alt text: Cross-sectional diagram of the colon showing diverticulosis with outpouchings and diverticulitis with inflammation and microperforation, highlighting the anatomical differences between the two conditions relevant to diverticulitis diagnosis.
In Western populations, diverticulosis is quite common, estimated to affect approximately 30% to 40% of individuals, and potentially even higher as many cases are asymptomatic. In fact, during colonoscopies, diverticulosis is a frequent finding, observed in around 42.8% of all procedures and increasing to 74.1% in individuals over 80 years old.
Diverticulitis arises when these diverticula become inflamed or infected. It’s estimated that up to a quarter of people with diverticulosis will develop diverticulitis in their lifetime. The term diverticulitis signifies inflammation and infection within a diverticulum, often resulting from a microperforation. The most common symptoms of acute diverticulitis are abdominal pain and fever. In the United States alone, diverticulitis leads to approximately 150,000 hospital admissions and 24,000 elective surgeries annually. The infection in diverticulitis is typically polymicrobial, involving a mix of anaerobic and facultative bacteria. Commonly implicated organisms include Bacteroides, Peptostreptococcus, Enterobacteriaceae, viridans streptococci, and enterococci. Diverticulitis is classified as either uncomplicated or complicated, based on the presence of abscess, fistula, obstruction, or free perforation.
Pathogenesis of Diverticulitis
Traditionally, the development of diverticulitis was attributed to the blockage of the diverticulum’s neck by a fecalith. This obstruction was thought to lead to bacterial overgrowth, inflammation, and eventual perforation, spreading inflammation to surrounding tissues. However, recent research suggests a shift in understanding, proposing that alterations in the gut microbiota may play a crucial role. These microbial changes can disrupt mucosal immunity, leading to chronic inflammation. While localized infections from microperforations may form contained abscesses, larger abscesses resulting from macroperforations can lead to more severe complications such as peritonitis, fistula formation, and systemic illness.
Why the ER vs Urgent Care Decision Matters
Choosing between an emergency room and urgent care for diverticulitis diagnosis is critical because it directly impacts the timeliness and appropriateness of care. Uncomplicated diverticulitis can often be managed in an outpatient setting, making urgent care a viable option for initial assessment and treatment. However, complicated diverticulitis requires immediate and intensive medical intervention, necessitating emergency room care and likely hospitalization. Misjudging the severity and seeking care in the wrong setting can lead to delays in crucial treatment, potentially worsening the condition and increasing the risk of complications. Therefore, understanding the signs and symptoms that differentiate uncomplicated from complicated diverticulitis is paramount in making the right decision about where to seek medical attention.
Recognizing Diverticulitis: Symptoms and Physical Exam
When diverticular disease is suspected, a thorough history and physical examination are crucial first steps in diagnosis and determining the appropriate care setting.
History of Present Illness
Key questions to ask patients when taking a history include:
- Dietary habits: While previously thought to be linked, current evidence is re-evaluating the role of specific dietary factors like nuts and seeds. However, general dietary patterns and fiber intake are relevant.
- Systemic symptoms: Inquire about fever, chills, nausea, vomiting, and general malaise, which can indicate infection and systemic involvement.
- Significant comorbid conditions: Underlying health issues like diabetes, heart disease, or kidney disease can influence the severity and management of diverticulitis.
- Immunocompromise: Conditions or medications that weaken the immune system increase the risk of complicated diverticulitis and require more urgent and aggressive management.
- Localization of pain and radiation: Diverticulitis pain is typically in the left lower quadrant, but location and radiation patterns can help differentiate it from other causes of abdominal pain.
- Previous colonoscopy: Knowing the history of colonoscopies is important for follow-up recommendations and assessing the risk of underlying conditions.
Physical Examination Findings
Common presenting signs and symptoms of diverticulitis during a physical examination include:
- Abdominal pain in the left lower quadrant (LLQ): This is the most frequent symptom, present in 93% to 100% of patients.
- Fever: Present in 57% to 100% of cases, indicating inflammation or infection.
- Leukocytosis: Elevated white blood cell count, found in 69% to 83% of patients, also suggesting infection.
Additional signs to look for during the physical exam:
- Guarding: Involuntary muscle contraction in the abdomen in response to palpation.
- Rebound tenderness in the LLQ: Pain that worsens when pressure is suddenly released during abdominal palpation, indicating peritoneal irritation.
- Tenderness in the suprapubic area: May occur, although LLQ is more typical.
- Hypoactive versus normal bowel sounds: Altered bowel sounds can suggest ileus or obstruction.
- Palpable abdominal mass: May indicate an abscess or phlegmon.
- Fecaluria or pneumaturia: Passing feces or air in the urine, suggesting a fistula to the bladder.
- Feces or flatus through the vagina: Suggests a fistula to the vagina.
Differential Diagnosis
It’s important to consider other conditions that can mimic diverticulitis, including:
- Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS)
- Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD)
- Carcinoma of the colon
- Endometriosis
- Ischemic colitis
- Infections (e.g., gastroenteritis, appendicitis)
- Lactose intolerance
When to Suspect Complicated Diverticulitis (ER Red Flags)
Certain symptoms and signs should raise suspicion for complicated diverticulitis and warrant immediate evaluation in an emergency room rather than urgent care. These “red flags” include:
- Severe abdominal pain: Pain that is excruciating, constant, and worsening, not controlled by over-the-counter pain relievers.
- High fever: Temperature above 102°F (39°C), suggesting significant systemic infection.
- Signs of sepsis: Rapid heart rate, rapid breathing, confusion, low blood pressure, indicating a body-wide infection.
- Significant comorbidities: Patients with conditions like diabetes, heart failure, kidney disease, or compromised immune systems are at higher risk for complications and should be evaluated in the ER for diverticulitis.
- Peritoneal signs: Guarding, rebound tenderness, and rigidity on abdominal exam strongly suggest peritonitis, requiring emergency surgical consultation.
- Inability to tolerate oral intake: Severe nausea and vomiting preventing oral hydration and medication.
- Signs of fistula: Fecaluria, pneumaturia, or fecal vaginal discharge.
Patients presenting with these red flags require immediate and comprehensive evaluation in an emergency room setting due to the potential for life-threatening complications. Urgent care centers are typically better suited for patients with milder symptoms suggestive of uncomplicated diverticulitis.
Diagnosing Diverticulitis: Imaging and Accuracy
While clinical evaluation based on symptoms and physical examination is often the starting point for diverticulitis diagnosis, it’s important to recognize its limitations. Studies have shown that approximately half of patients diagnosed with diverticulitis solely on clinical grounds are later found to have other conditions. Therefore, imaging studies play a crucial role in confirming the diagnosis and assessing the severity of diverticulitis.
The American College of Radiology recommends computed tomography (CT) as the initial imaging modality of choice for patients presenting with abdominal pain in the lower quadrants, whether left or right. Figure 2 illustrates typical CT findings in diverticulitis.
Alt text: Axial CT scan of the abdomen showing sigmoid diverticulitis with pericolic fat stranding, a key radiological indicator for confirming diverticulitis diagnosis and distinguishing it from other abdominal pathologies in emergency settings.
Both CT and ultrasound can be used to evaluate diverticulitis, but CT is generally preferred due to its superior sensitivity (97%) and specificity (100%) in diagnosing diverticulitis, as detailed in Table 1 of the original article. While ultrasound can be highly accurate, its reliability is more dependent on the operator’s experience. Conventional radiology (plain X-rays) has limited diagnostic value and is not recommended for evaluating suspected diverticulitis.
Urgent Care vs ER Diagnostic Capabilities
Emergency rooms are equipped for comprehensive diagnostic imaging, including CT scans, which are the gold standard for diagnosing diverticulitis and assessing for complications. This allows for rapid and accurate diagnosis, especially in cases where complicated diverticulitis is suspected.
Urgent care centers may have limited on-site imaging capabilities. While some urgent care facilities may offer ultrasound, CT scans are generally not available. This means that for patients initially evaluated in urgent care, if diverticulitis is suspected and further imaging is needed for confirmation or to rule out complications, they may need to be referred to an emergency room or radiology center for a CT scan.
Therefore, for patients with symptoms suggestive of complicated diverticulitis or when there is diagnostic uncertainty, initial evaluation in the emergency room is advantageous due to immediate access to CT scanning. For patients with milder symptoms and a lower suspicion of complicated disease, urgent care can be an appropriate first step, with the understanding that further imaging in an ER setting might be necessary if the diagnosis remains unclear or symptoms worsen.
Treatment Approaches: Urgent Care vs Emergency Room Management
The treatment strategy for diverticulitis is largely determined by whether the condition is uncomplicated or complicated and, consequently, whether management is initiated in an urgent care or emergency room setting.
Uncomplicated Diverticulitis: Outpatient Treatment (Urgent Care Role)
Outpatient treatment is generally recommended for initial management of uncomplicated diverticulitis. This approach is also considered appropriate for diverticulitis with a small peridiverticular abscess (less than 3 cm), as detailed in Tables 2 and 3 of the original article. Urgent care centers are well-positioned to manage uncomplicated cases.
Antibiotics: The role of antibiotics in treating acute uncomplicated diverticulitis is currently under review. Emerging evidence suggests that inflammation, rather than infection, may be the primary driver in many cases of uncomplicated diverticulitis, questioning the routine use of antibiotics. Recent randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews focusing on hospitalized patients with CT-diagnosed uncomplicated diverticulitis have indicated no clear benefit from antibiotic therapy in this specific inpatient setting. However, these studies primarily focused on inpatient treatment and uncomplicated cases, and their findings cannot be directly extrapolated to complicated diverticulitis or outpatient management.
The American Gastroenterological Association (AGA) recommends individualizing antibiotic use in select patients with acute uncomplicated diverticulitis rather than routine prescription. Outpatient treatment of acute uncomplicated diverticulitis without antibiotics has not been extensively studied. In urgent care, the decision to prescribe antibiotics for uncomplicated diverticulitis should be based on individual patient factors, considering the severity of symptoms, presence of comorbidities, and clinical judgment.
Complicated Diverticulitis: Inpatient Treatment (ER/Hospital Role)
Patients with complicated diverticulitis require inpatient treatment and antibiotics (Table 4 of the original article). Complicated diverticulitis includes cases with abscesses larger than 3 cm, fistula, obstruction, perforation, or peritonitis. Additionally, patients who are immunosuppressed, pregnant, exhibit signs of systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) or sepsis, or have significant comorbid diseases should also be hospitalized for diverticulitis management. The emergency room is the appropriate setting for initial evaluation and stabilization of these patients, followed by hospital admission.
Criteria for Inpatient Referral
Key criteria for referring a patient with diverticulitis to the emergency room and potential hospital admission include:
- Complicated diverticulitis: Presence of abscess (especially >3cm), fistula, obstruction, perforation, peritonitis.
- Severe symptoms: Uncontrolled pain, high fever, signs of sepsis.
- Immunocompromised state.
- Pregnancy.
- Significant comorbidities: Conditions that increase the risk of complications or make outpatient management less safe.
- Failure of outpatient treatment: Worsening symptoms or lack of improvement despite initial urgent care management.
Initial Treatment in Urgent Care vs ER – Key Differences
In urgent care for suspected uncomplicated diverticulitis, initial management may include:
- Pain management: Over-the-counter pain relievers or prescription analgesics.
- Dietary recommendations: Clear liquid diet initially, progressing to low-fiber and then high-fiber diet as symptoms improve.
- Antibiotics: Potentially, depending on individual patient assessment and clinical judgment, especially if there are signs of infection or risk factors for complications.
- Outpatient follow-up plan: Instructions to follow up with primary care physician within a few days.
In the emergency room for suspected complicated diverticulitis or high-risk cases, initial management will be more aggressive and may include:
- Comprehensive assessment: Including detailed history, physical exam, and immediate CT scan.
- Intravenous fluids: For hydration, especially if there is vomiting or signs of dehydration.
- Intravenous antibiotics: Broad-spectrum antibiotics are typically initiated promptly.
- NPO (nothing by mouth) status: To rest the bowel.
- Surgical consultation: May be necessary for complicated cases, especially those with large abscesses, perforation, or peritonitis.
- Hospital admission: For ongoing monitoring, IV antibiotics, and potential surgical intervention.
Follow-Up and Long-Term Management
Appropriate follow-up is crucial after an episode of diverticulitis, regardless of whether initial management occurred in urgent care or the emergency room.
Urgent Care Follow-up
For patients with acute uncomplicated diverticulitis managed in urgent care, follow-up with their primary care physician is recommended within 3 to 5 days to monitor symptom resolution. If antibiotics were prescribed in urgent care, this follow-up is particularly important. Patients should be advised to return to urgent care or seek immediate medical attention if their condition does not improve with conservative treatment or if symptoms worsen.
Colonoscopy Recommendation
The AGA recommends a colonoscopy after an episode of acute diverticulitis has resolved to exclude underlying colorectal neoplasms. Colonoscopy is typically scheduled 6 to 8 weeks after the acute event, although the optimal timing is not definitively established. Referral to a gastroenterologist for colonoscopy is appropriate in these cases.
Surgical Consultation
Surgical consultation with a general surgeon may be necessary for some patients with diverticulitis. Elective surgical resection is currently recommended for patients with more than two episodes of diverticulitis. However, the decision for surgery should be made on a case-by-case basis, weighing the risks and benefits of surgery against potential complications such as infections, anastomotic leak, and cardiovascular events. Factors to consider when referring for surgery include:
- History of two or more diverticulitis episodes.
- Lack of improvement with conservative treatment.
- Generalized peritonitis or severe systemic symptoms.
- Immunocompromise.
- Uncontrolled bleeding.
Prevention Strategies
Preventing recurrent episodes of diverticulitis is an important aspect of long-term management. Lifestyle and dietary modifications play a key role.
- High-Fiber Diet: While evidence is not conclusive, a high-fiber diet is generally recommended to promote bowel regularity and potentially reduce recurrence risk. It is important to discuss potential side effects like bloating with patients when increasing fiber intake.
- Physical Activity: Regular vigorous physical activity has been associated with a decreased risk of diverticulitis recurrence.
- Avoid NSAIDs: Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), except for aspirin, should be avoided in patients with a history of diverticulitis due to an increased risk of recurrence.
- Nuts and Seeds: Contrary to previous beliefs, current evidence suggests that consuming nuts, corn, and popcorn does not increase the risk of diverticulitis or complications.
Mesalamine, rifampin, and probiotics are not currently recommended by the AGA for routine prevention of diverticulitis recurrence due to insufficient evidence of benefit.
Continuity of Care: Urgent Care, ER, and Primary Care Collaboration
Effective management of diverticulitis often involves a coordinated approach across different healthcare settings. Urgent care centers play a crucial role in initial evaluation and management of uncomplicated cases, while emergency rooms are essential for complicated cases requiring immediate and intensive intervention. Primary care physicians are vital for ongoing follow-up, long-term management, and preventative strategies. Seamless communication and collaboration between these settings are crucial to ensure optimal patient care and outcomes in diverticulitis management.
Conclusion
Diverticulitis is a common cause of abdominal pain frequently encountered in urgent care and emergency room facilities. The current treatment landscape for diverticulitis is evolving, with ongoing research and updated guidelines. Current recommendations emphasize outpatient management for acute uncomplicated diverticulitis. Patients with complicated diverticulitis or those with significant comorbidities, immunosuppression, peritoneal signs, or evidence of abscess, fistula, or perforation require transfer to a hospital for inpatient treatment. Understanding the distinctions between uncomplicated and complicated diverticulitis and recognizing the appropriate setting for diagnosis and initial management – whether urgent care or emergency room – is crucial for ensuring timely and effective care and minimizing the risk of complications. Further research is needed to refine treatment strategies and improve outcomes for patients with diverticulitis.
References
- Cartwright S, Knudson Diagnostic imaging of acute abdominal pain in adults. Am Fam Physician. 2015;91:452–459.
- Brown H, Kelso Abdominal pain: an approach to a challenging diagnosis. AACN Adv Crit Care. 2014;25:266–278.
- Bhuket TP, Stollman Ileus and pseudo-obstruction. In: Feldman M, Friedman LS. Sleisenger and Fordtran’s Gastrointestinal and Liver Disease. 10th edition. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier; 2016:2123–2138.
- Sifri CD, Madoff Diverticulitis and typhlitis. In: Bennett JE, Dolin R, Blaser MR, eds. Mandell, Douglas, and Bennett’s Principles and Practice of Infectious Diseases. 8th edition. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders; 2015:986–989.
- Stocchi Diverticulitis. In McNally PR, ed. GI/Liver Secrets Plus. 5th ed. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier; 2015;358–364.
- Stollman N, Smalley W, Hirano I; AGA Institute Clinical Guidelines American Gastroenterological Association Institute Guideline on the Management of Acute Diver- ticulitis. Gastroenterology. 2015;149:1944–1949.
- Ferri Diverticular disease (diverticulosis, diverticulitis). In: Ferri’s Clinical Advisor 2016. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders; 2016:434.
- Piper MS, Saini Diverticular diseases: a modern renaissance? Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2015;14:104–106.
- Strate LL, Liu YL, Syngal S, et Nut, corn, and popcorn consumption and the incidence of diverticular disease. JAMA. 2008;300:907–914.
- Tursi A, Danese Preventing diverticulitis recurrence by selecting the right therapy for a complex disease. Gastroenterology. 2014;147:733–736.
